Plastic vs. Metal Window Well Covers: Which Is Best for Grand Forks Homes?

When it comes to protecting your home from the elements, especially in areas with harsh winters like Grand Forks, North Dakota, window well covers are a must-have. These covers help protect basement windows from debris, water damage, and even the occasional wildlife intruder. But with so many options available, homeowners often find themselves torn between plastic and metal window well covers. Both materials offer advantages and drawbacks, and understanding these can help you make an informed decision for your home. So, which is the best choice for Grand Forks homes: plastic or metal window well covers?

The Role of Window Well Covers in Grand Forks

Before diving into the debate between plastic and metal, it’s important to understand why window well covers are essential, particularly in regions like Grand Forks. The climate here is characterized by long, cold winters, heavy snowfall, and strong winds. These conditions can lead to significant water damage, rusting, and debris accumulation in window wells, which are the depressions surrounding basement windows.

A well-designed Plastic window well covers Grand Forks, ND serves several purposes:

Protection from the elements: It keeps rain, snow, and debris (leaves, branches, dirt) from filling the window well, which can lead to water seepage and basement flooding.
Prevents accidents: An open window well can be a safety hazard, especially for children or pets. A sturdy cover ensures no one accidentally falls into it.
Energy efficiency: Keeping the well clear of snow and ice helps maintain the temperature around your basement windows, preventing drafts and energy loss.

Now that we understand why window well covers are important, let’s compare the two main types: plastic and metal.

Plastic Window Well Covers

Plastic window well covers are a popular choice for many homeowners due to their lightweight nature and affordability. Here are some of the benefits and drawbacks of choosing plastic:

Advantages of Plastic Window Well Covers

Lightweight and Easy to Install Plastic covers are generally easier to handle and install compared to metal ones. They can be secured with minimal effort and are often available in DIY-friendly kits. This can save on installation costs if you’re a handy homeowner.
Affordability Plastic covers are typically less expensive than metal options, making them an appealing choice for homeowners on a budget. This is especially relevant for homeowners who need to cover multiple window wells.
Rust-Free Plastic is impervious to rust, unlike metal, which can corrode over time when exposed to moisture. In a place like Grand Forks, where winter conditions are harsh, this can be a significant benefit, as rust can damage the integrity of metal covers.
Transparency Some plastic covers are made with clear or translucent materials, allowing natural light to filter into basement windows. This can brighten up your basement space and provide some level of visibility, making it a preferred option for those looking to maintain the look and feel of their lower levels.
UV Resistance Modern plastic covers are often UV-resistant, meaning they won’t degrade or discolor as quickly as older plastic options. This helps maintain their appearance and effectiveness over the years.

Disadvantages of Plastic Window Well Covers

Durability Concerns Although plastic is resistant to rust, it can be prone to cracking or breaking, especially under heavy snow or ice load. Grand Forks’ long winters with frequent freeze-thaw cycles could potentially shorten the lifespan of plastic covers. While some plastic types are reinforced to withstand these conditions, they may still be more fragile than metal.
Aesthetic Appeal While plastic covers are functional, they might not always blend as seamlessly with your home’s exterior as metal covers do. For homeowners looking for a more premium or refined appearance, plastic might not be the best option.

Metal Window Well Covers

Metal window well covers are another popular choice, often chosen for their strength, durability, and aesthetic appeal. They come in a variety of metals, with steel and aluminum being the most common.

Advantages of Metal Window Well Covers

Durability and Strength Metal covers are extremely durable and can withstand heavy snow and ice buildup, which is a crucial consideration for homes in Grand Forks. Unlike plastic, which can crack under pressure, metal covers provide long-lasting protection and are less likely to be damaged by harsh winter weather.
Security Metal covers can offer a higher level of security than plastic ones. They are difficult to lift or remove, making it harder for animals or intruders to get inside your basement. This can be particularly important if you’re worried about potential break-ins or unwanted wildlife.
Aesthetic Appeal Metal covers often have a sleek, modern look that can enhance your home’s curb appeal. They can be custom-made to fit your window wells and are available in a variety of finishes, including powder-coated options that resist rusting and fading.
Weight While heavier than plastic, metal covers’ additional weight can be a positive feature in some cases, as they tend to stay put during high winds. This can be particularly important in areas like Grand Forks, where strong winds are common.

Disadvantages of Metal Window Well Covers

Potential for Rust While some metal covers, like aluminum, are naturally resistant to rust, steel covers can begin to corrode over time, especially in areas with a lot of moisture. This can lead to maintenance issues and a reduced lifespan. However, powder-coated steel covers can resist rust much better than traditional steel options.
Cost Metal covers are generally more expensive than plastic ones, both in terms of upfront cost and installation. If you’re on a tight budget, this could be a deciding factor.
Installation Complexity Due to their weight and design, metal covers may require professional installation, especially for custom-fit covers. This adds to the overall cost compared to plastic covers, which are often more DIY-friendly.

Making the Right Choice for Your Grand Forks Home

When deciding between plastic and metal window well covers, consider the following factors:

Budget: If you’re looking for a more affordable option, Plastic window well covers Grand Forks, ND might be the best choice. They’re inexpensive and easy to install, offering good value for homes on a budget.
Climate and Durability: If you’re concerned about the harsh winters in Grand Forks and need something that can stand up to snow, ice, and freezing temperatures, metal covers, especially those made of aluminum or powder-coated steel, may be the more durable choice.
Aesthetics: If curb appeal is a priority for you, metal covers often look more polished and can be customized to suit your home’s design.
Maintenance: Plastic covers require less maintenance but may need to be replaced sooner if they crack. Metal covers, though more expensive, may last longer with proper care, particularly if you choose rust-resistant finishes.

Ultimately, both materials have their strengths. If you’re looking for a balance of durability and cost-effectiveness in the Grand Forks climate, plastic covers are a great choice. However, if you’re willing to invest more upfront for longevity, security, and aesthetics, metal covers might be the right option for your home.

By carefully considering your priorities, you can ensure that your window well covers will protect your home for years to come.

Reference: Window well extensions

Reference: Egress windows installation near me